Recent Comments

Headlamp or flashlight?

headlamp-200x148Q. What’s better for the outdoors: a headlamp or a flashlight?
— Looking-for-a-light Larry, Orlando, Fla.

A. Larry, this is a good question. The biggest benefit to using a headlamp that’s strapped to your noggin is that it provides hands-free lighting. That means when you’re on an outing, you can cook, hike, read in your tent, go to the bathroom, etc. without holding a flashlight. Also, headlamps tend to be more compact and lighter weight than conventional flashlights. Headlamps usually have variable light levels and many also come with a flashing emergency light option. Sure, flashlights are great, but I’d say for the average Boy Scout a headlamp is the best choice.

Ask the Gear Guy

Not sure which gear to buy? Need tips for maintaining your equipment? Click here to send in your questions for the Gear Guy. Selected questions will be answered here and in the printed magazine.

23 Comments on Headlamp or flashlight?

  1. i like flashlight beter

  2. Jakinator2005 // November 8, 2015 at 8:16 pm // Reply

    I have a headlight, and its great, but there are some problems. once I was playing Manhunt my strap came out of the bracket and fell off, causing me to trip. Conclusion= headlights aren’t the greatest for running.

  3. The only issue I see with head lamps is that the darn thing generally ends up pointed at a face when taking with someone.

  4. SurplusDude // June 12, 2014 at 6:14 am // Reply

    I really like the Princeton Tech Byte. Its a really good flashlight. After i got mine, it hasn’t left my side since. When mine breaks i’m getting another one!

  5. i use a headlamp and bring a hat light for backup

  6. Ihazporkchop // May 22, 2014 at 7:42 pm // Reply

    I would say flashlight because they are usually brighter and you can hold it in your mouth

  7. Eagle4Life // May 21, 2014 at 5:29 pm // Reply

    One of my biggest issues is that the headlamp allows you to adjust it to point it at different lengths along the ground, but as I walk it inevitably just falls down and shines straight into my eyes.

  8. I jus got a random flashlight. :3

  9. How about both in one unit? I carry a Micro Mag light (1 AAA battery size) with an elastic head strap (Included) that converts the flashlight to a head lamp. The light has 2 settings, bright and low light. Cost $10.00 (for both parts). Actually though, my favorite is the button light by Nite Eyz. This light attaches to a zipper pull, offers enough light for the tent and a stroll to the bathroom in the woods. These cost about $4.50 each and are the size of your thumb nail. I carry 2 on all outings.

  10. i carry boyh a a mini-mag and a cyclops that positionable so you can point it down

  11. headlamps are goodbut keep a backup

  12. Headlamp wins over flashlight for scouting. It keeps you hands free so you can work in the dark, and it is a must for caving. Usually a headlamp costs less too, and now they come in LED bulbs, so the batteries last longer.

  13. Since I started using a headlamp, I will not go in woods without.Mariofan has good advice though carry a handheld as a backup.I recommend both using the same type of batteries, and not rechargeable. These tend to lose their recharge life and are expensive to replace.

  14. Definately true.Though,aim for a, at least, 1 watt light or 60 lumenends. Anything less than that tends to be annoyingly dull, and you’ll always be thinking you have low batteries.

  15. headlamp less chance of breaking because u dont hold it so it does not fall and break

  16. Boy Scout Man // October 9, 2009 at 6:12 pm // Reply

    I agree with Mahiawa very strongly!!!

    Nice tip!!!!!!

  17. I like my headlamp best, but I would say both. You never know when you will experience equipment failure. Always have a plan B!

  18. Look for a headlamp with a red or green light so you don’t blind your buddies at night. Aim for an LED light, the batteries will last a lot longer.

    • moscoutmom // May 21, 2014 at 9:11 am // Reply

      My two year old got a headlamp with a red light option for Christmas. He put it on his nose and said he was Rudolph. 😀

  19. I like headlamps best, but they all ways get into the people that you are talking to’s eyes.

Leave a Comment

Please don't use your real name.